"When love leaves us, may we not revise what happened. May we read our love like a favorite book, and shelve it next to all great love stories. Let’s always tell the world that yes, yes I loved that book. And while I won’t remember every plot change, the minor characters, the conflicts and resolutions–I’ll remember that our love moved my heart to another part of my body. If you put your ear to my ear, you’ll hear it there still, skipping like a broken record." --Jenn @ Choose Our Own Adventure
Saturday, May 30, 2009
Quote of the day: On past love stories.
Tuesday, May 26, 2009
Happy second anniversary to us / F-U Prop 8.
Quote of the day: Kanye West doesn't really read but he'd like you to.
Tuesday, May 19, 2009
City as Beloved, City as Character: A LibraryThing Early Review of Colum McCann's "Let the Great World Spin."
Literature functioning as love letter to New York city is ubiquitous. Writes E. B. White in his famous tome, Here Is New York: “The city is like poetry: it compresses all life, all races and breeds, into a small island and adds music and the accompaniment of internal engines” (1949:29). Walt Whitman’s verse is physically inscribed on the body of the city itself: his knighting of New York as “proud and passionate city—mettlesome, mad, extravagant city” graces the long railing of the lower Manhattan Esplanade along the Hudson, while his entreaty, “Stand up, tall masts of Mannahatta! Stand up, beautiful hills of Brooklyn!,” greets visitors at the Fulton Ferry landing in DUMBO, Brooklyn, as they stroll along the old wooden dock, licking historical ice cream cones. Just to name a few, Paul Auster, James Baldwin, Michael Chabon, Michael Cunningham, Herman Melville, Henry Miller, Eugene O’Neill, J. D. Salinger, and the younger ilk crowding the pages of the New Yorker’s and New York Times’s Book Reviews sections such as Jonathan Safran Foer and Colson Whitehead—the infamously dubbed “Brooklyn writers”—have likewise had no shortage of verbiage on the subject of city as beloved. But even amongst such august company, Colum McCann’s Let the Great World Spin rises like crème de la crème to the top.
What makes McCann’s novel so breezily fresh and new is his detailed presentation of not one slice of the city but several: he gives his readers a taste of the whole big beautiful apple. A safe remove of eight years has made it possible to write again of New York city without needing to reference the tragic events of September 11, 2001, even if just to plot one’s literature along some imaginary timeline in the sky, B.S.11. or A.S.11, coming off cold and distant for having dealt with one’s duty only by describing which buildings appear in the skyline or, alternately, resulting in a heavy, melodramatic hand in trying to acknowledge the emotion of a thing seemingly beyond words.
So the time is ripe and we readers are hungry for a book that holds at its center the Twin Towers in such an unexpected way: on August 7, 1974, Phillipe Petit, funambulist extraordinaire, successfully walked across a wire strung high and tight between the newly completed World Trade Center towers. True story. McCann takes this marvelous tidbit of truth and structures around it a fantastic fiction that has nothing to do with 9/11 and in other ways everything to do with it. His novel contains no terrorists in our contemporary understanding of the word, but there is a guerilla performance artist, demonstrating our need for rigidity and rules, flaunting the flaccidness of our national and city security, and bringing to the surface our voyeurism, our inherent instinct towards rubbernecking at car crashes, our desire for excitement and spectacle. In a place where locals won’t even raise their eyebrows, never mind turn their heads, to watch a man in his underwear singing accompaniment to his own guitar smack in the neon stretch of median down Broadway—brights lights big city Times Square—we will stop in our tracks, we will let our coffee grow cold, we will share elbow room with and talk to complete strangers when a life hangs in the balance. There is not space enough in this review to consider the psychological reasons for our obsession with death, but there you have it: how to get our attention, or, as McCann words it in the first sentence of his prologue (with considerable more elegance), “those who saw him hushed” (2009:3).
Following the third-person, omniscient point of view of the prologue, which places us in time and space (August 7, 1974, a quarter-mile in the sky on a wire stretched between the Twin Towers), McCann gives flesh to the following: the blood brother of an Irish priest now living in New York; an affluent woman of the tony Park Avenue set; a female artist who we would today gloss as a “hipster”; a teen photographer obsessed with subway graffiti; a young computer hacker in California; a prostitute living in the Bronx; a Judge who must decide the funambulist’s case; the Hispanic woman who the aforementioned Irish priest loved; an African-American woman who lost three sons to the Vietnam War; and the young daughter of a dead prostitute. Ten disparate slices of New York that, when fit together in place and time, add up to the whole apple. In addition, threaded through these ten chapters is that single tension-tight wire: the reoccurring return to Phillipe Petit, who figures into each of these lives.
These many points of view, in McCann’s capable hands, accomplish what they should: as Dave Jauss suggests in “From Long Shots to X-Rays,” a craft meditation on point-of-view and narrative technique, “Handling point of view is much more than a matter of picking a person or a narrative technique and sticking with it; rather, it involves carefully manipulating the distance between narrator and character, moving closer one minute, then farther away the next, so as to achieve the desired response from the reader” (2008:50–51). The effect is that the city—as lived by such different people, as seen through such different points of view, situated in race, class, age, culture, et cetera, as points of view are—itself becomes a multidimensional character, a complicated, flawed, even “human” character who, to borrow again from E. B. White, “[bestows] the gift of loneliness and the gift of privacy” (1949:19) and “can destroy an individual or fulfill him, depending a good deal on luck” (1949:19) but also “makes up for its hazards and deficiencies by supplying its citizens with massive doses of a supplementary vitamin—the sense of belonging to something unique, cosmopolitan, mighty and unparalleled” (1949:33). For the writer picking up the pen in such a place, how can what results be anything but a love story?
It is only in the last chapter of the book that McCann acknowledges the pink elephantine events of 9/11. He has let sit for 322 pages the fact that he is writing about the Twin Towers at their beginning rather than at their end. But, in that last chapter, “Roaring Seaward, and I Go,” narrated in the third person by a young woman named Jaslyn, we are placed in an airplane, itself a poignant choice, in the October of 2006. McCann is so smart about this timing: he writes about the very thing we’ve all been obsessed with since 2001, but he does so considerably before and considerably after the tragedy that so escapes words. Jaslyn’s mother, a prostitute, died on that same day that Phillipe Petit tightrope-walked the towers, and Jaslyn carries with her a photograph of Petit walking in the air with a plane suspended in the background. As nimbly as the funambulist upon the wire, McCann dances across our synapses, making the connection we’ve waited for all 322 gorgeous pages preceding: “A man high in the air while a plane disappears, it seems, into the edge of the building. One small scrap of history meeting a larger one. As if the walking man were somehow anticipating what would come later. The intrusion of time and history. The collision point of stories. We wait for the explosion but it never occurs. The plane passes, the tightrope walker gets to the end of the wire. Things don’t fall apart” (2009:325).
It is in that last sentence that McCann skewers the character of New York and her people. He shows how she has grown from 1974 to 2006, her resilience, both buoyant and cold. He flays open whatever it is about her that makes her residents so alone despite being crowded by an excess of 8.2 million people squished together in less than 305 square miles (Wikipedia n.d.), whatever it is that makes them wall themselves off from human contact yet become a family during times of crisis (e.g., the blackout of 2003) and tragedy (e.g., again, 9/11), whatever it is about them that yearns to belong to her, to this place “unique, cosmopolitan, mighty and unparalleled” (White 1949:33), to this place ahead of every curve and triumphant survivor of any tragedy, to this city where “things don’t fall apart.”
REFERENCES CITED
Jauss, Dave
2008 Alone with All That Could Happen: Rethinking Conventional Wisdom about the Craft of Fiction Writing. Cincinnati, OH: Writer’s Digest Books.
McCann, Colum
2009 Let the Great World Spin. Advance copy for LibraryThing Early Reviewers’ Program. New York: Random House.
White, E. B.
1949 Here Is New York. New York: The Little Bookroom.
Wikipedia
N.d. New York City. Electronic document, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_City, accessed May 19, 2009.
Colson Whitehead on being a "Brooklyn Writer."
Monday, May 18, 2009
Six entries later ...
LOL @ that last entry.
The silence and the noise.
5/16 Brooklyn Flea roundup.
Just a spoon full of Cheetos makes the broccoli go down.
I miss you, blogiverse.
Monday, May 11, 2009
What to eat at Momofuku Milk Bar.
The second time I went I thought "ehhhh" to the glazed-donut soft serve.
The next time a friend bought me candybar pie, I thought YUMMM and HAPPY BIRTHDAY TO ME, INDEED.
And the last time I went, I thought OH MY GAWD CRACK PIE . . . and damn!! for the blueberry cookies.
In conclusion: Skip the soft serve unless it's the pistachio a friend of mine swears by. Don't question what's in the crack pie, just eat it, it's fricken delicious. And if they have cookies, eat cookies. Calories so don't count when they taste this good.
Why I need a personal assistant.
Because I have a pile of filing to do and no desire to sit there doing it.
Because I hate--HATE--standing in line at the Post Office.
Because I wish someone else would answer the phone calls and handle the call backs, and do both with more regularity and punctuality, resulting in me looking less like an asshole.
Because I'd have someone else to talk to, besides my dog.
Because maybe it would get me out of my pajamas more often. Well, it's possible, anyway.
Because I need to believe that if the little things were dispatched with, I'd have time and desire to do The Big Things.
Because what if someone else was constantly making sure I had enough coffee, oh sweet dream of mine?!
Because maybe I'd remember to eat more than three cups of coffee and dinner.
Because of Murphy's Law: just when I've sat down and really gotten going on The Big Things (balancing my checkbook, early editing an issue of American Anthropologist before crunchtime, writing my novel, revising short stories, etc.), the dog has to go to the bathroom.
Well, hello there.
After a few days of tromping about the city with Neil, we three headed to Pennsylvania to meet up with the rest of the gang: Dave's mom, dad, grandma, auntie, uncle, other cousin, cousin's wife, and cousin's two children. Whew. There was small talk made, there were gaps filled, there were cheesesteaks eaten and daytripping around Philly done, there was too much outlet shopping (I am Officially Broke now), there was eating, there was drinking, and there was staying up late in our hotel room, still working on getting Neil to move to NY.
After that was done, Mom, Dad, and Grandma Poe came to New York, and we walked and shopped and devoured our way through this city.
It was in all ways delightful, in all ways needed, in all ways completely enjoyed . . . but now I feel like I need to nap for three days straight. And also get some work done. Not to mention try to catch up on Facebook and all 59 blogs I read, all of which seemed to unfortunately undergo periods of heavy productivity in my absence.
Consider the sleeves rolled up.
---
* E. B. White. Here Is New York. New York: The Little Bookroom, 1948.
